Designing a 1600kVA/35kV, 50Hz Distribution Oil Transformer and Oil Tank

General Information

Technical Specification

Input voltage

3 x 35000/20230V, star
sine wave

Transformer output voltage

3 x 400/230V, star

Line output current

3 x 2319A,
continuous operating mode

Frequency

50Hz

Ambient (air) temperature
and

Min. oil temperature rise

25C

35K

Max. winding temperature rise
and/or

max.winding
losses at 75C

65K

18000W => 1.125%

Short-circuit voltage

6.5%

Short-circuit voltage

6.5%

Max. core losses

3200W => 0.2%

Max. oil temperature rise
at 21200W

60K

Max. no-load current

1.3%

Test Voltage at 50Hz, 1 minute

Primary 85kV, outside
Secondary 4kV, inside

 

Steel & Core Assembly

30P110, annealed, strips for alternated stacking
(4x45+3x90 per shape),
"round" cross section with 8 steps

 

Core Size

Optimized for minimal material price for:

Al_Price/Fe_Price = 1

with Al-winding

 

Creating Input

4 input screens are used to set the input parameters for designing a transformer:

         Winding parameters per limb

         Core

          Environment

         Other

and 3 screens for selection and set up of material :

         wires

         steels

         cores.

Criteria and Parameters of Design

 The design of a distribution transformer is always framed by 5 criteria which have to be put into effect simultaneously:

        Short-circuit voltage

        Winding losses at 75 C

        Winding temperature rise

        Core losses

        No-load input current

Under this condition the first step is the optimizing the core size to match the above mentioned prescribed design criteria for the optimal material price using some additional parameters such as:

        Cooling media

        Testing voltages

        Steel quality and core assembly

        Winding type and wire type & material

        Cu/Al and Fe price relationship (per kg)

Normally the user of this software will create an optimized core family for a typical design criteria and parameters and select a desired core per click. In order to demonstrate the procedure for core optimization, note that the following parameters of optimization are a summery of 5-6 designs:

        Max. winding losses at 75 C = 18000W

        Inductive short-circuit voltage = 6.4%

        Max.winding temperature rise 65K at the ambient (air) temperature 25
For the winding losses 18000W with the winding temperature rise to the average oil temperature of approx. 15-2
0 K both windings need to have very big cooling surface using min.of 3 vertical cooling channels in both windings. The used  windings construction is presented in the next picture. It is optimal because there is no need for any transposition within the high current winding and there is no need to worry about the pulse voltage distribution and partial discharging between the layers within the high voltage winding

 

In order to avoid very high circulated losses within a foil winding (max. 5% is a good value) you need to follow these rules:

  1. Use Al-foil instead  Cu foil.
  2. In order to reduce the radial magnetic field on the top & bottom of the foil winding set the distance h > 0 (normally between 15-30mm)
  3. Increase the distance d between the leg and the first foil winding

The high voltage winding has to have only 3 layers with 6mm cooling channel between them. Due to this fact the rectangular wire has to be wound over the smaller wire side. Normally this winding type has higher eddy-current losses but using Al-rectangular wire the eddy-current losses can be easy limited to max 10%

        Max. core losses = 3200 W

        Max, no-load current = 1.3%
These 2 criteria of design can be easy realized with annealed strips of 30P110 (M110 H,30ZH110, ...) grain oriented steel at the induction 1.75T with the following shape and 8 steps "round" cross-section:

        For 85kV, 50Hz, 1 minute high voltage test  and the power 1600kVA  the following min. spacing is recommended:

a01=17mm; a12=27mm ;a22=30mm
δ01=δ12=5mm (tubes)
δ22=3mm ; δш=2mm ( 2 x overlapped to increase the creaping distance to the yoke)
l01=l02=75mm
lц1=lц2=50mm (tube width over the windings))

Note that the creeping distances between the HV-windings and the LV-windings & the core have to be bigger than 125mm.

 

Windings parameters per limb

Primary

The primary is created in star connection. The sine wave input voltage is 20230V .
There are no voltage harmonics and there is no duty cycle operation mode.
The primary will be manufactured with Al-flat wire in cylindrical winding technology (view picture above) with 3  vertical cooling channels of 6mm between 3 layers. The advantage of this winding configuration is low voltage per turn and no problems  with  partial discharging  and pulse voltage distribution. In order to suppress the effect of the high pulse voltage you can add easely stronger insulation to the10 first and 10 last turns of the winding.

Secondary

The secondary winding is set inside. It is wound with Al-foil and 0.2mm insulation between the turns. In order to increase the cooling surface the secondary is cut in 3 coils. Between them are 6mm cooling channels. Due to the fact that the first winding to the leg has higher circulated currents than 2 other coils its number of turns should be smaller than the number of turns of 2 other coils.

The sine wave output voltage is 230V.
The rms output current  is
2319A.  There are no current harmonics.
Also, there is no duty cycle operation mode on the secondary.

With the eddy current losses factor (RacRdc) 1.1 the number of parallel wires & foils will be limited . Note that at this point of the design you cannot prescribe the wire or foil size  . You can select only the wire family which the program must use in order to select the suitable wires or foil for your application.
 

Core

On this input screen you can :

         select and manipulate the selected steel 30P110 (M 111 H, 30ZH110, 30H110). This steel has the losses of 1.1W/kg at 1.7T, 50Hz 1nd >1.88T at 800A/m.

         set the operating induction (1.75T) and the frequency (50Hz)

         select the core assembly 7 (view the picture above)

         and prescribe the core selection out of an input file. This option will not be used because the core size has to be optimized by program.

Environment

The ambient (air) temperature is 25C
The cooling medium is oil with the minimum oil temperature rise on the oil tank bottom of 35K Note that this temperature rise has to be fine-tuned during the oil tank design in the Test Mode..

The cooling surface of the core is increased by using 4 L-brackets on the core. The minimum distance between the primary outside coils of 2 phases is 30mm. There is no flange but both windings have to be fixed in order to suppress the axial forces during the short circuit operation mode.
There is no air in the windings nor the  gaps between the windings and insulations!

Other

Here you can set the criteria for  design (winding temperature rise or winding losses at any temperature) and/or the criteria for optimization for the minimum of the material price.

The selected criteria of the design and core optimization are the winding losses (18000W => 1.125%) at 75 C  and the inductive short-circuit voltage 6.4%. Note that the program can NOT optimize (but it can calculate) the losses of the circulated current in the foil changing winding material and spacing  because this has to be set by designer only. Due to this fact the prescribed windings losses are set to 1.05% instead 1.125%

 If you prescribe also the winding temperature rise then the program has to use the criterion which is more critical: either the winding losses or the winding temperature rise with the prescribed inductive short circuit voltage.
The core losses and the no-load input current can be manipulated only with steel quality, core assembly and  induction

If the ratio of the price per kg between the windings and core material is 1 then the transformer is optimized for minimum price and weight.

Core optimization

After you have set all input screens you need to select a core family and a core as template: 3 phase core family with 8 steps "round" cross section

Click Core to open the input screen for reading the parameters of the selected core

Click Optimize to optimize the core.

The yellow output fields are optimal results. Both other columns have a higher material price for 2%.

At this point you have to check whether the active and reactive core losses are within the prescribed range:
Active core losses = 2175W < 3200W
Reactive core losses = 16803VAr = 1.05% < 1.3%

The next check what the effect of the radial mechanical forces are during the short-circuit operation mode:(7.33 N/mm2 < 25 N/mm2, max. allowed for Al) and the average winding temperature rise to the average oil temperature (5.962K < 15K)
Here you can round off the core diameter (213mm instead 212.8) and click Create. This is the optimized core .

 

Output

The first step of the presentation of the output screen is DIAGNOSIS: it is the summary of the most important calculated parameters of your transformer.
Windings losses at 75C Uccr = 1.1% < 1.125%
Inductive short-circuit voltage Uccx = 6.21% <> 6.4%
Winding temperature rise to the ambient (air) temperature is 56K < 65K

The second very important output screen is the Test Mode. In this program part the transformer can be manually fine-tuned and redesigned.

First you need to round off the number of turns. Then to set equal foil thickness for 3 secondary coils and finely to select by hand a rectangular wire (wound over the smaller wire side) to get one full layer per each primary coil.

Here is the finally result

Here are some remarks to this design:

  • Very simple winding construction.
  • Winding losses 17604W < 18000W
  • Reactive short-circuit voltage 6.3% < 6.4%
  • Windings temperature rise 53K < 65K
  • Max. oil temperature rise 55K < 60K
  • Core losses 2134W < 3200W
  • Reactive core losses 16092 = 1% < 1.3%

Here are 4 printed pages with all input and output parameters of the transformer

Page 1

Page 2

Page 3

Page 4

 

Oil Tank

During the transformer design the minimum oil temperature rise on the bottom of the oil tank (common for all windings) was set to 35K. The calculated transformer and oil temperatures are presented in the following diagram:

Legend:

  • 1 => Core
  • 2,5,7,9,11,14,16,18 => average oil temperature in the cooling channels
  • 3,4,12,13 => surface of the insulation
  • 6,8,10,15,17,19 => average winding temperature

Note that the program calculates the max. oil temperature and the oil flow (the amount per second) in the cooling channels and the max. oil temperature on the top of the oil tank as the average value of the mixed amounts of the oil  on the exits of the cooling channels. In this case the max. oil tank temperature is 80.58C (the temperature rise 55.58K<60K)

From thermal point of view the program supports the following 8 types of oil tank cooling:

 cooling:

In the first step you need to set the size of the "naked" oil tank. For your reference the dimensions of the calculated transformer are presented on the top of the input screen. The result of your settings in this input frame are the oil tank dimensions, the amount of the oil and the max. oil temperature rise of the "naked" tank. Note that the amount of the oil  is calculated without the coolers (fins, tubes and radiators).

The next step is the setting of the cooler. In this case the selected cooler is with cooling fins

After you set the size of the cooling fins the program will calculate the max. available number of the fins and the max. oil temperature rise. You can change the fin size or reduce the number of fins in order to get max. oil temperature rise approx 55.58K. If you set the max. oil temperature rise at 60K (changing the cooling fins)  then you need to redesign the transformer with the min. oil temperature rise 39.42K (instead 35K).

Circulated Current Losses

Note that the program uses the numerical calculation of the magnetic fields. Due to this technology the calculations of the circulated current losses is very powerful.
The following pictures show the magnetic field inside  of the core window by the margin of the secondary winding 75mm  and 45mm. You can see that the radial magnetic field through the top of the secondary winding  is stronger with the margin 75mm and the circulated current losses higher:

  • The primary margin=75mm, the secondary margin=75mm => the circulated current losses = 1300W/phase
  • .
  • The primary margin=75mm, the secondary margin=45mm => the circulated current losses = 220W/phase

 

 

 

 

Eddy current losses

Due to high voltage line discharge and for a good pulse voltage distribution the first & last 10 turns  have to be additionally insulated with approx 0.75 - 1.00mm insulation.

From the manufacturing point of view is the primary winding construction optimal but from eddy current losses point of view it is only a "good" compromise: 13% (instead 2-3%) more losses in the primary winding 

Radial Tension

 Normally the Al foil winding is more sensitive to the mechanical forces in the short-circuit operation mode. Max. allowed tension in the cross section of a Al wire or Al foil is 25 N/mm2. In our design example the max. tension is 11.73 N/mm2  

Winding temperature rise in the short-circuit operation mode

 The max. winding temperature rise in the short circuit operation mode after 4 seconds is 52.44K. The max. winding temperature after the short circuit operation mode out of the nominal operation mode will be 25+54.2+52.44 = 131.64C